Last fall and winter, we entered Book Design Made Simple in some independent publishing book award contests. In mid-April, we got word that our book had won gold at the Independent Publisher (IPPY) Book Awards. Nine days later, we won another gold medal, this time at the Next Generation Indie Book Awards.
After some discussion, we decided to attend both award ceremonies and Book Expo America (BEA) in Chicago. We reasoned that we would meet new people (indie publishers being our audience, after all), find out what BEA was all about, learn something by attending the conference sessions, and display our book at the Independent Book Publishers of America (IBPA) booth. And we’d be awarded our gold medals in person! After all, how often does that opportunity arise?
We managed to accomplish all of those goals, and enjoyed visiting Chicago at the same time. So what can we share with you about indie book award contests, to help you decide if they are right for you? Here’s what we’ve learned about the pros and cons of book award contests:
Pros of entering indie book award contests
Ego. An award can do wonders for your head! It can give you the mental boost you need just as you begin to wonder if the entire publishing venture has been worth the effort. Frame those medals! Or wear them! Later on you will get a lift from looking at them and the memory of receiving them.- Status. You’ll be able to display medals and stickers on your book, website, email signature, display table, and anywhere else you can think of.
- Money. Contests can be expensive (entrance fees are usually between $75 and $200 USD per category), but a few contests offer cash prizes to top winners. As gold medal winners in the Next Generation Indie Book Awards, we won $100 USD.
- Networking. If you attend an awards ceremony, meet as many other award-winning authors as you can, and compare publishing experiences. Offer to swap reviews, visit each other’s websites, and sign up for each other’s blogs. Connect on social media and post photos online. Make the most of your big night.
Discovery. Whether you win an award or not, you will learn something about the value of your book. If you didn’t win an award or become a finalist, take some time to think about why your book didn’t win. Are there already too many books on your topic? Did you hire a professional editor? Is your design as good as the others? Did you enter in an appropriate category? Our book won gold twice in the Writing/Publishing category, but so far is a finalist in the Reference category. So the former category is a much better fit for us, but not all contests include that category.- Fun. Enjoy your visit to the city! Build in some tourist time for yourself to make it a truly memorable trip.
Cons of indie book award contests
These contests are not the National Book Award or the Newbery Medal or the Man Booker Prize. Not even close. It seems that the major publishing houses haven’t heard of them. But that doesn’t mean they are worthless by any means. If you pick the contests carefully you can avoid the pitfalls. What pitfalls? Here are a few:
- Costs. All of the contests cost something: There’s an entry fee, and the cost of shipping multiple copies of your printed book (ebooks generally upload for free). Compare fees, and read about possible additional expenses if you win (such as purchasing stickers for your book or attending award ceremonies). Most contests produce good revenue for the sponsors, and some are even referred to as “pay-to-win” events that award all entrants. (We know of only a couple of not-for-profit contests.) In every case, the sponsors gain by increased traffic to their website as you spread the news of your win.
- Your bottom line. If you win, will your book sales spike to reflect your glory? Probably not, unless you work really hard at marketing. Despite doing just that, we didn’t notice any difference in book sales, and nor did any other winning authors we asked.
- Possible scam. Some are not really competitions at all, but simply ploys to get you to use a vanity press or self-publishing service. If you are invited out of the blue to enter one of these “contests,” be wary and read the fine print.
Is it worth entering book award contests?
That depends on you, your book, and what you hope to achieve from entering contests.
We asked several book award winners whether they thought entering contests was worthwhile. Most agreed that they noticed no increase in sales. However, it was unanimous that the awards reception, the medal, and the ability to put a sticker on their book was worth the entry fee, but not more.
Trena White at Page Two Strategies shared her thoughts: “We know from Booknet and Bookscan sales data that very few book awards actually help to sell books. The Giller Prize in Canada certainly does and the Pulitzer does, but most make no measurable difference. Still, awards are helpful for signalling a book’s quality to the book trade and to potential readers, and they can have a positive effect on writers’ careers. They’re prestigious and that’s valuable too.”
Was it worth it for us? Definitely. Did book sales increase and did we recover the costs of entering the contests? No. But people do take notice that our book has won awards, even if they’ve never heard of those particular awards. Potential readers assume that our book was judged by competent professionals in the publishing world, and was deemed by them to be one of the best in its category. So our book has gained prestige. And who knows what the long-term benefits will be? (That’s a blog post for next year!)
Which book award contests to enter
Which contests offer more pluses than minuses? Below is a list of reputable ones that have been around for a while. Because of the expense, we recommend entering no more than half a dozen contests. Research each one for yourself and see if it is right for you and your book. Don’t try to squeeze it into a subject category that doesn’t fit; simply try another contest. Most of the contests are open to international publishers if their books are written in English. In alphabetical order:
- Benjamin Franklin Book Awards, put on by the Independent Book Publishers Association (IBPA), is a big one. This organization has over 3,000 members, and among the membership, this is the most coveted award. It’s also the only one that shows you the judges’ comments about your book.
- The Eric Hoffer Award has been around since 2000 and is well respected as an independent entity with no corporate ties. It has fewer categories than some other contests. Cash prizes are offered.
- Foreword Review’s IndieFab Awards (soon to be called the “Indies”) strings out their process for a long time. They announce a suspiciously long list of finalists early on and then offer expensive advertising opportunities in their magazine. Even so, it is a popular contest.
- Independent Publisher (“IPPY”) Book Awards is run by the Jenkins Group (a book marketing firm) and is clearly a for-profit venture. However, they have built up a good reputation over twenty years. There are also several offshoots of the IPPYs, such as business and children’s book contests.
- National Indie Excellence (NIEA) Book Awards is run by Smarketing, a book marketing firm. A few overall winners are given valuable book promotion packages through outside companies.
- Next Generation Indie Book Awards is the largest not-for-profit contest. It is put on by the Independent Book Publishing Professionals Group in cooperation with Marilyn Allen of Allen O’Shea Literary Agency. After the ceremony they follow up with encouraging emails and general advice on how to leverage a win to improve sales. Cash prizes are awarded.
- Smaller-scale contests are run by some of IBPA’s regional affiliate organizations. These awards are also coveted and can result in decent sales to fellow members.
- USA Best Book Awards is sponsored by USA Book News and i310 Media Group. They offer good support for winners on their site and through press releases, plus they make connections with the entertainment industry.
- Whistler Independent Book Awards, new in 2016, is open to Canadian self-published authors. Each book receives a thoughtful critique that can be quoted for publicity. One interesting advantage to this contest is that the books can be up to 6 years old when entered. No ebooks.
- Writer’s Digest Self-Published Book Awards offers valuable prizes. The top winner receives not only a large cash award but also a feature article in Writers Digest, a press release that is sent to major publishers, and a free trip to the award ceremony. Other winners receive cash or Writer’s Digest books.
What do you think? Should you send your book off to be judged alongside others? Are you confident that you have a professional product that can compete and perhaps even win? Does your book offer new information or make a unique contribution in some other way? If you think so, and your book has received honest, enthusiastic reviews, then go for it. But remember that most contests only judge books and ebooks that are fresh off the press. So do it now!
Read more: Our book sales: three years in » Learn from our book marketing journey.
Read more: Book marketing to libraries » Try this method with the people you meet at award ceremonies!
And even more: Your book promotion materials » Additional ways to tout your awards.
Book Design Made Simple. You can do it yourself.
Thanks Glenna for your very helpful post. Do you have any feedback or comments on NYC Big Book Awards run by Gabby Olczak?
Hi Paul,
This book awards contest seems to be relatively legit. The people running it are experienced, and it’s related to the Independent Press Awards. I looked at the 2020 winners, and they seem to be mostly self-published, so at this point, the big publishers are ignoring these awards. The entry price seems a bit steep, though you can check the current entry fees for some other awards to see how they compare. There are a huge number of categories to choose from! (Just think of the $ they make per category!) So the factors to weigh are, not necessarily in order of importance:
–The cost (try to enter in only one category unless you think your cover design could be a winner)
–The advantages of winning (they offer attractive bookmarks, and of course you can add your “medal” to your cover and publicity)
–The chances of winning (it’s all indie publishers right now, which is an advantage)
–How many other awards contests you will enter and how much money you want to spend. I’d put this one farther down on your list.
–Read the publicity online from the various winners. Just do a search for this contest and you’ll see a lot of announcements from proud winners. You could write to some of them to see if the publicity helped them at all.
Also, Paul, before you plunge in, please read this article: https://booklaunchers.com/book-award-scams/. Notice that there is no list of judges, or even a mention of judges, on the NYC Big Book Awards site. Make sure you’re confident that this contest is worthwhile FOR YOU.
Best of luck, whether you enter or not. If you do, please let us know how it went and whether it was worth your time and money. Thanks.
Glenna
I can tell you that my experience with this Gabby person and her organization does not cause me to think they’re legitimate at all. Nearly two months ago, I reported to them that a book that they had given an “award” to contained direct copy and paste plagiarism from a book I’d written and published 10 years earlier. This book has been pulled from Amazon and other books sellers on CI grounds. I have yet to hear back from this organization and I’ve sent emails with my evidence of infringement and left voicemail messages. To me the whole ‘literary award’ thing smacks of a money making scam that has nothing to do with literary excellence. Otherwise they’d be a little bit concerned that one of their awardees is a plagiarist.
Hello Nora,
What award program are you complaining about? If they’re on our list, we will remove them. Plagiarism can’t be tolerated.
These programs do seem like an easy way to make a lot of money, but actually the logistics of mailing the books to the judges and getting comments back involve quite a lot of work and expense. Some are run with more of a sincere desire to reward excellence than others.
Glenna
Unfortunately, you can’t just claim plagiarism without a time cycle to investigate it, and it took Amazon almost 30 days to take the book down, and it was off the Independent Press Award site within 60 days. Results matter. Shame it looks like this complaint was just missed within days it seems. The author reprinted the book, giving credit to Ms. Lenz, yet we still did not repost it on our site.
I see the Benjamin Franklin Book Awards, listed at the top of this award list (IBPA not IPA) still has the book in question still posted, What the Pet Food Industry Is Not Telling You: Developing Good Practices for a Healthier Dog 2022 Silver Winner at https://www.ibpabenjaminfranklinaward.com/winners-animal-pet now FOUR years later, yet no one addressed here, and you still have at the top of your list. I’m not bashing that award program, and do think it’s a reputable one, but goes to show the uneven treatment.
We take plagiarism very seriously, and work through a process. We do it fairly as there are many people that have alternative motives that are not disclosed upfront, and I admit we are not as fast as Amazon, but we get the job done.
The independentpressaward.com is a reputable book award program that does so much more for authors that the other award programs. Each awardee is given free support, be it press releases (yes, we provide free template AND free set up for all who want it) to free consultation with no obligation of purchase of any kind of paid offering. We do not use strong arm tactics to purchase ‘packages’, which so many other programs offer. We provide a couple of different creatives with their winning status at no charge that they can use on social media or their website. We freely support our authors.
We couldn’t be more sincere in rewarding excellence, and backing that up. What program continues to help market and support authors well after the award is done. Everyone gets listed on our magazine, more than once, which is available via Libby at your local library, or https://issuu.com/independentpressaward
We don’t measure our success by others, we measure it with the authors and publishers we serve, and stand by our commitment to them.
I
I’m so glad that I read this blog and others that evaluate ‘
Award groups’ . I wish I had read this two years ago. I have two children’s books that have “won” Gold” medals. Now I wonder if these awards are being seen as a mockery among my competitors. Will I be seen as naive on the industry? Mike
Hello Mike,
As you read in our article, some awards are worth more than others. Since you didn’t mention which ones you won, I can’t comment on their worth. In general, though, I don’t think you need to worry too much. Your readers most likely do not know one award from the next and will probably be impressed with anything you’ve won. Have you shown your awards on the front or back cover? If so, and if you’re marketing the book to bookstores or distributors (companies that are savvy about awards) plus appearing at events alongside your competitors, and if you’re worried that the awards are a bit bogus, then remove them for your next printing and stop mentioning them in your marketing.
If you want to tell me which awards you received, I will respond privately about them.
Glenna
Hi glenna, in you’re professional opinion is the Eric Hoffer Award Book contest legit? Or is it a vanity scam?
Hi Brian,
The Eric Hoffer Awards are among the more prestigious ones. As to whether it will boost your sales, I suggest that you look at their testimonials (Success Stories) page. Most of them express gratitude, but a few do claim a boost in sales.
Glenna
Thanks for all of this wonderful info!!! Do you have any thoughts on the ALSC awards – such as the Caldecott?
Hello Brett,
The Newbery and Caldecott awards are the very best, as I’m sure you know. Many people, including myself, will choose a book just because it has one of these award stickers on it. These awards seem to be open to any U.S. publisher (they make no mention of the publisher’s size).
I admit that I have never heard of any of the other awards given by the ALSC, but if your book fits any of the categories and you believe it is the very best in that category, then go for it. It seems there’s no charge for entering, but you should still keep your submissions down to one or two per title.
I hope this helps. Let us know if you win!
Glenna
Thanks Glenna! I appreciate your input!
Hi Brett just curious did you win?
Thanks for this great article! I am committed to entering my newest novel, Motherless Child, into some of these contests because it took many years to write, the final product is highly professional, and I would like some validation that my efforts are at the level I believe them to be. I am disappointed to hear that short term sales do not seem to be affected, and I wonder if at least libraries take more notice of Independent award winners.
Thoughts?
Adam Cole, A Jazz Musician Who Writes Books
Hello Adam,
The amount of attention paid to indie book awards probably varies from one library to another. For the most part, librarians read Publishers Weekly and Library Journal. Publishers Weekly does book reviews for a very few, highly selected books, and those are the ones that are purchased first. After that, I’m guessing that books that are advertised in those 2 journals are occasionally purchased. (Join IBPA to get your book into those ads.) Without that kind of exposure to librarians, books have very little chance on their own.
Have you read our blog post about our own self-pub book marketing journey? You might find it enlightening (https://www.bookdesignmadesimple.com/book-sales-three-years/). We also wrote about a small-scale but effective scheme to get books into libraries (https://www.bookdesignmadesimple.com/book-marketing-to-libraries/).
In a general sense, it’s very nice to be able to plaster book award stickers all over your book, and we do hope you win some! But please don’t count on them to bring you additional sales. The contests do not actually do any marketing for you–you’re still on your own. With that said, though, we encourage you to go out there and get some awards. At the very least, if you go to the ceremonies, you will meet some interesting authors and perhaps exchange books along with some good marketing tips.
Glenna Collett, coauthor
The Pushcart Prize Award the Newberry Award and the Pulitzer Prize Award do increase Book Sales!
Thank you Glenna Collett for such detailed information about Book Awards. You have given me a complete point-by-point decision-making process that by the end of reading your article I knew — I don’t need to enter any awards. I will concentrate instead on Book Promotion and Marketing.
Olga Gladky Verro, Author Memoirist of two Memoirs published on January 15, 2019: (1) “In the Web of History: Old Russia and Soviet Union: and (2) “Nikita Khrushchev’s Teacher: Antonina G. Gladky Remembers: With Unique insight into Nikita Khrushchev’s Politically Formative Years as Communist Politician and a Rising Party Leader” Abridged from ITWOH. Available in HC, PP, eBook, Kindle and iApple.
Hello Olga,
We are very glad we could help you decide whether to enter book award contests. The decision is different for everyone, depending on personality, time, budget, etc. Now that you know not to bother with the contests, you can spend your time and energy on promotion. Best of luck with your book marketing efforts!
Glenna